Reaksi DAP kepada tuduhan mencabul (tidak terbukti) yang membabitkan anak Lim Guan Eng.
Kajian penggunaan kata-kata dan gaya bahasa:
I. Kenyataan media Guan Eng
Umno 3D – “Desperate, Dangerous and Dirty tactics”
(a) Kanak-kanak
“Young son”, “young kid”, “young children” digunakan 11 kali untuk merujuk kepada anak lelakinya yang berumur 16 tahun.
Perkataan remaja – dalam bahasa Inggeris “teenager” atau “youth” – yang sebenarnya lebih tepat untuk menggambarkan seorang lelaki 16 tahun tidak disebut sekalipun oleh Guan Eng.
(b) Tidak berdosa
Guan Eng merujuk 3 kali kepada kes anak lelakinya (16 tahun dan kononnya hendak tukar sekolah kerana mahu simpan rambut) dengan kata sifat “innocent” dan “innocence”.
“his innocence so cruelly destroyed”
Perkataan “child / children” digunakan 5 kali.
(c) Buas, kejam sekali
Tentang blog pro-Umno dan sesetengah pemimpin parti itu:
- “the pro-Umno ferocious beasts”, “these ferocious pro-Umno beasts”, “the pro-Umno beasts”
- “cruelly dragging in my young 16 year old son”
- “maligned in such a beastly and cruel fashion publicly”
(d) Parti barbarian dan pembohong
“with their lies”
“I deplore these lies and fabrications against my young son”
“these lies … as morally despicable and barbaric”
“cruel and barbaric lies”
“My son is very shaken up by these lies”
“many Umno leaders rehashing the lies”
“Khairy Jamaludin joined in these shameful lies”
“spreading lies at my young son … trauma of such lies”
Perkataan “lies” digunakan sebanyak 8 kali.
Sumber: Blog datuk kepada kanak-kanak mentah dan tidak tahu apa-apa itu
II. Kenyataan media pengerusi DAP Pulau Pinang, Chow Kon Yeow
“Umno’s politics of dirt and grime”
“Umno resorts not only to playing up ethnic and religious tensions but also to manufacturing sex scandals”
“Umno must now make a stand. Can you be civil and well-mannered? Or are you a party full of jokers, scoundrels and liars?”
“band of Umno bloggers to mouth vile and evil words”
Chow denied claims that Pakatan practised ‘gutter politics’ or that it abused the children of its opponents. – Sumber: Kalau tak Malaysiakini, mana lagi?
Yakah anak bini orang Umno dan MCA tidak pernah diserang oleh Pakatan?
Seingat saya Puan Chua Soi Lek dan anaknya masih lagi kena kau-kau walaupun sudah 4 tahun sejak video ‘itu’ dibocorkan. Pakatan people, so petty, and ‘porn actors’ always on their mind.
Dan selama ini bagaimanakah perdana menteri telah respon? Malah serangan peribadi bukan sahaja terhadap isteri dan anak-anak Najib Razak bahkan menantu dan besan juga.
Beginilah. Senang sahaja.
Kutipkan data empirical dan tengok segala apa yang pernah dilemparkan terhadap ahli keluarga para pemimpin negara. Lepas itu boleh kita buat bandingan dari segi kuantiti dan tahap ‘longkang’nya.
AKAN BERSAMBUNG: Reaksi konco-konco dan para penyokong DAP
Anda juga mungkin meminati:
Helen Ang 
Kalau tiada angin takkan pokok bergoyang. Dalam berkata-kata, nampaknya makin ramai rakyat Malaysia yang sudah hilang kesopanan dan kesusilaan. Maklumlah, mereka ini tidak berpandukan Rukunegara.
Helen.
What are you up to? Do you mean that when somebody killed my brother in the past, I can kill that somebody’s brother? Must the casualty of my brother’s life be justified by a revenge on that somebody?
Likewise, just because CSL’s wife get humiliated every day does not mean that LGE’s son deserves to get that kind of humiliation.
Let me digress a bit. You mentioned on the other day that LGE’s son used to study at a Chinese school. So, what’s wrong with that?
For your information, I had been studying at national schools since primary one until I completed my form 6. During this period of time, I had witnessed quite a number of racial incidents at my schools. If you were an Indian student, how would you feel when a Malay District Educational Officer calls you “Keling”?
What about a Senior Assistant telling a group of Chinese students to crossover to a neighbour Chinese school for causing disciplinary problems at school?
Maybe the existence of vernacular schools has caused disunity to happen in the country, but that does not mean that national schools do not play the role of a unity spoiler.
________________________________________________________
Probono writer,
I’ve written here and elsewhere several times that I support Chinese school. It is the DAP darlings who will cause Chinese schools to be abolished.
Take Hannah Yeoh and Guan Eng’s pol-sec Ng Wei Aik for instance. They listed down their race in official forms as Anak M’sia. If you’re Anak M’sia, you go to Kebangsaan school (why enrol in ‘Chinese’ school?). If you’re not Chinese (and they’re not b’cos they’re fighting the govt to be declared Anak M’sia) and DAP supporters are not Chinese or Indian (b’cos they claim to be Anak Bangsar M’sia) and hence there will eventually be no officially defined Chinese/Indian races in M’sia, then can you pls tell me how one can justify the existence of vernacular schools? — Helen
Do you know who introduced the concept of Bangsa Malaysia? It was Mahathir. What happened to Mahathir’s Bangsa Malaysia concept 20 years later after he coined the term?
Why do we even need to state our ethnicity while filling out a form (say a registration form to sit for SPM exam)? Isn’t this fishy? Isn’t this a form of racial polarization also?
If Chinese and Indians are ready to give up their schools, are Muslim community too willing to follow suit by giving up their Sekolah Agama?
What is the fuss all about if children of Anak Malaysia are sent vernacular schools? After all their children are learning Bahasa Kebangsaan also, aren’t they? Even a child of Md Isa Sabu (Perlis MB) is currently attending SJK(C) Khoon Aik?
I am a Malaysian Chinese. Does that mean I must only eat Chinese food? No ketupat? No mutton curry? And no tapai? That’s ridiculous.
woi…bono,
Helen is commenting on chow statements : “Chow denied claims that Pakatan practised ‘gutter politics’ “… showing that Pakatan or their pro-medias have been using gutter politics since the begining of the day…..
in other words, Helen is trying to show that Pakatan is full bunch of liars ! Salndering has been Pakatan SOP (standard operatioin procedure) !
since when, Helen say two wrongs make it right ? or you also learn from Pakatan style of deception ?
________________________________________________________
Bukan Chow sahaja tetapi Guan Eng juga mendakwa: “UMNO politicians have children too and DAP have never gone for their children and do not intend to so.” — Helen
Woi Awal.
Isn’t posting entries like this slandering? The blogger has been picking on DAP leaders. Isn’t this slandering? Why only DAP leaders? Why Lim Guan Eng only? Are you sure our government leaders are clean? Have they not committed any sin? Kuman di seberang nampak. Gajah di depan mata tak nampak.
Gutter politics huh? Is it wrong for the opposition to demand for explanations whenever suspicions over suspicions occur? Is it wrong for the opposition to check and balance on what our government is doing? When Mahathir himself admitted that he squandered RM100 million during his tenure, you expect the opposition to keep quiet?
_________________________________________________________
Is it wrong for the authorities to get to the bottom of the allegations? Molest/outraging modesty is a crime, you know. So is bribery. — Helen
woi bono,
do you understand what slandering is ? Let me teach you. Slandering is making false statement on someone to damage the reputation… in malay it is call FITNAH. Please note the word ‘false statement’.
now, go and read back the article. Each line in this entry is referring to the statements made by Lim Guan Eng and some other comments. It is not false statement ! It is the fact ! the real word coming out from guan eng and the bunch. So, it is not slandering !
Guan Eng is the target because he is the one making the statement. Why you are so difficult to understand this simple fact ?
It is not wrong to demand explanation…., but it is wrong to make a false statement like the one did by guan eng !
sandiwara ini baru di peringkat awal. apabila landskap berubah sepenuhnya, ia akan menjadi pentas lebih mencabar. pada masa itu hanya mereka yang kuat mentalnya dan bagus lakonannya akan terus mendapat tempat di hati penonton.
Good idea Helen. Orang Pakatan ni perasan bagus. Yang dia orang dengan selambanya menuduh DS Najib pembunuh tu apa dia? Civil sangatlah tu. Walaupun ini lebih kepada strategi tak bermoral PKR, tapi DAP merestuinya. Anyway, lets not pretend that empirical evidence can change the mind of PR followers.
Can somebody officially confirm with the school the story of a pupil whom went to the extent of transferring school just for the want of having longer hair?
Wow
Willing to sacrifice so much ie transfer school-leave behind best friends-change transporting routine just for the sake to have a longer hair.
Incredible !!
Can’t the old school just give some leeway if the said pupil so badly wants a few extra cm of hair, being a VVIP son and all
Amazing
Can also somebody verify the said regulation of the short-hair-requirement-school – good to double check the hair length of existing pupils – are any pupil’s hair freely touching the collar?
Perhaps also it is good that an independent commission or investigation be established for this(upon an official report by someone)
Cheers
:)
Helen,
The choice of words – “teenager” or small kid/child is irrevelent here. It is not about what LGE called his kid. It about the gutter politics that went on to slander on LGE’s family.
You can go on to say that BN’s leader endured a much worse situation. However, do this matter? Do 2 wrong make a right? Do it mean that – if you killed my family member, i can kill one of your family member back. If you murdered 2, i can take another 2 innocent family members of your’s? If indeed you are the “national school” product, you have brought much shame to the “national school” and i wished you were from the vernacular school instead. Buat malu kaum, bangsa dan negara.
Lastly, what pisses people – Please do a better work when slandering people. Such a low class act of “copy and paste” slandering work is really annoying. Go see for yourself – the victim of the molest(or should i say the slader) http://www.chessbase.com/newsdetail.asp?newsid=3980.
– Ex National School Grad
p/s: i don’t really expect you will post this. BUT anyway…. Just trying my luck
You say: “i don’t really expect you will post this.”
Oh really? Whatever makes you think that? Another DAP-type insinuation? Have you ever heard any complaints anywhere that I censor comments?
I’m the Tuan Rumah of this blog.
You people come here to my cyber home as guests and leave comments — such as “You big fat slob!” — defacing my most personal page (see ‘About Me’)
as well as make other comments like “Helen Ang is just another whore of dumno lar” (here), and
“Bad enough that you should sell your body to EVIL umno and mca for a few ringgit, but you also sell your soul as well…for free” (here)
and other insults that show how M’sian Firstest commentators lack manners.
All of these comments get published, and yet here you are anticipating me to refuse to let your piffling one through? Do your homework first lah.
And another thing, you’re bringing coal to Newcastle by asking me to look at the girl’s picture as my blog had already carried the story about the ‘identity theft’ of the photo even before the two Pakatan cheerleaders Malaysiakini and Insider came out with their articles.
(You can verify my claim through the time stamps.) It’s just two postings before this one — again you made a statement that only indicates your ignorance.
Next time, do a bit of reading before you come here declaring that I “Buat malu kaum, bangsa dan negara”, can ah?
Thinking that you will censor my comment – My bad
Did not do enough homework, and assumed that you did not know it was an identity theft of the “victim” – My bad
Calling you a “national disgrace” – that still stand. why?
I believe irregardless of which school we attended since young(be it agama for the muslim or pendidikan moral for the non muslim), none of them ever thought us to “tit for that” or an eye for an eye. You seem to think it is fine since your idolized BN leaders been dragged through a stinkier mud. Hence, it is an acceptable culture in Malaysia.
Also, stop avoiding the main question/concern i brought up here. You knew very well, what was being questioned. Instead of addressing them, you choose to pick the seemly small, irrevelent matter. Perhaps, guilty as charged?
_________________________________________________________
Homework for you. Read this, written shortly before this.
yeah, u didnt mention gutter politics by dap. it is good for dap to do it the first time, but its wrong for umno to retaliate…
wow, that is crap of the highest order…
get a grip son, loser like yourself is an embarrassment..
Tengok semula u tube pasal budak perempuan cina(China) yang di gelek van tu….. sayu dan tersentuh amat hati. Benci sungguh melihat gelagat orang di sekeliling terutama ‘babi-babi’ yang bawa kenderaan itu !!!
Manusia bila hati dan perasaan dah mati, kejadian ZALIM berlaku di depan mata pun tidak menjadi kesalahan apa-apa…. malah bangga mementingkan diri, masih mengaku diri sendiri sahaja yang benar
Ini lah kebenaran manusia yang sama di Malaysia….bila cakap dan komen main sedap mulut saja…apa lagi yang kurang ?
Sejahat-jahat umno, kaum cina tetap menjadi kawan. Sejahat-jahat cina terus-terusan memintal awan dan hanya mencari kawan sepermainan !
“Is it wrong for the authorities to get to the bottom of the allegations? Molest/outraging modesty is a crime, you know. So is bribery. — Helen”
Do you even know what is the difference between “allege” and “malign”? Tuduhan dan fitnah adalah dua perkara yang berbezalah Kak Helen oii
Hi Helen Ang,
My name & blog was mentioned by Lim Guan Eng and siapa lagi kalau bukan MalaysiaKini & Malaysian Insider.
I was accused of revelaing LGE & son & school in my earlier article regarding the scandal.
And ur guess is correct. LGE, MalaysaiKini & Malaysian Insider manipulated my article to the fullest.
But still. They were caught red handed for lying! U know how LGE & this portal functioned right.
U can read my entry. Click : http://novandri.blogspot.com/2011/10/bongkar-anak-pemimpin-tinggi-politik.html
__________________________________________________________
Thanks Dr Novandri. I’m a regular reader of your blog. The Malaysian Insider is sneaky (beware). — Helen
Novandri,
It is proven that LGE’s son has never known the alleged victim. You are not remorseful. You call yourself a Muslim but you are very despicable. Beware of the tribulations that you will undergo in your afterlife. May you perish in hell
is it already proven meh?? Do you know the alleged victim?? Have you spoken to her personally? Can you verify all this?? At least dr.novandri didnt even mention LGE name on the “said article”. LGE yang perasan sendiri kan..
may you perish in your prejudiced biased mindset on earth. Amin.
betoi. ini doktor novandri, helen ang, papagomo, khairy, dan geng yang segerombolan dengannya kena pedang sendiri.
wanita yg dikata kena cabul sebenarnya pemain catur british 21 thn yang hanya melawat mesia sekali saje.
kesian… satu hari bangun dan membaca foto diperguna di satu pelusok dunia.
apa bloggers ini mau mohon maaf dia? yea, “what about the girl”, huh? tak pun nak mohon maaf kepada rakyat mesia kerana cuba memperbodohkan mereka.
Haha kesian pemain catur pompuan tu. Satu hari bangun blur blur tak tau apa entah telah berlaku padanya
now im following you helen. keep up the good work. :)
They are paying attention to you now, Saudari Helen Ng. Must be something you have been hitting at that’s hurting them, raw nerves perhaps? At least, via their comments, we are all more aware of what they really are.
Dia orang tak ada apa lagi nak bangkitkan dah. Calling you names is the best they can do. Poor fellas. They do that everywhere lah.
My only hope is that after this LGE will become a better Chief Minister and not someone who thinks himself an opposition politician first and Chief Minister second.
if LGE’s son did not do it as alleged than just tell LGE to get the police to investigate and clear his name and that of his son…simple as that he cannot even do meh? NOSMOKE WITHOUT FIRE….